In Africa, it’s particularly tiring when our problems repeat themselves again and again in brand-new disguises. Just think of Nigeria’s 2023 presidential election, or the recent succession of coups in Mali and Burkina Faso: a rigged election today, a coup tomorrow, and national funds allocated to projects that never materialise. Many African students will recall the 2021 student-led protests in South Africa and Nigeria’s EndSARS movement, both demanding change yet frustrated by weak, resistant systems. We conveniently blame corrupt leaders and colonial history, but it can’t simply be a shortage of good people willing to serve their countries; rather, it lies in a fault in the design of the systems through which leadership is obtained and exercised.
Many of the structures that shape how power is won and used were shaped by a different Africa: smaller, rural, less connected, fewer youths, and less watched. That Africa no longer exists, and yet, unfortunately, the systems created to govern it still do.Many of these systems were designed around personal interest rather than national interest and survived because they remain useful mainly to those who benefit from them. So if we are reimagining leadership in Africa, we must consider who gets to lead our countries. How would we hold our leaders accountable? What yardsticks would we use to gauge the impact of their leadership? How would citizens participate in governance? Africa's leadership issue may not be about removing bad individuals from power; rather, we must examine the systems that allow poor leadership to thrive, strengthen the systems that hold our leaders accountable, and create a leadership model that responds to our current realities.
The System and Not Only the Actors
Africans have, over the years, conveniently and justifiably pointed at individual leaders who rewrite constitutions to fit their personal interests, who respond to opposition with violence rather than peaceful dialogue. When we focus on these individuals alone, we let the faulty systems off the hook: weak accountability systems that don’t make leaders consistently answerable to citizens; weak institutions, including judiciaries, legislatures and oversight bodies that cannot efficiently check executive power; and political systems that reward retaining power more than effective governing.
If Africans consider corruption, it’s important to look at the structures that reward and rarely punish corruption. With oversight institutions lacking funds and independence to function effectively, corruption can become normal within the political system. That’s why leadership transitions in some African countries are less like the peaceful handovers in mature democratic states and more like a fresh contest for control of the same fragile system. In functioning systems, the leaders answer to citizens all the time through free press, active legislatures, and independent judiciaries. Where the feedback chain is weak, leadership can become a performance of power instead of a responsibility to provide public services. So citizens are treated as an audience rather than principals to be served.
Why Africa’s Future Requires a Different Type of Leadership
Africa’s current leadership model prioritises controlling political power; however, it is no longer sufficient for a continent that needs to manage modern, complex societies requiring greater innovation, economic reforms, and sustainable development.
Economic challenges in Africa are not just a lack of resources but also how African economies are built and governed. A good number of African economies are dealing with huge debts, infrastructural gaps and a limited economic diversity. There’s a rise in youth unemployment due to Africa’s growing youthful population, making the need for effective leadership urgent. So a rapidly growing population and limited economic opportunities must be governed through political models that create conditions for long-term development, innovation and economic participation.
Our current model of leadership treats its citizens as passive recipients of government decisions, but Africa’s young population must be part of governance and decision-making in their respective countries. This should extend beyond voting in elections to representation in political institutions, policy development, and local governance. Playing a direct role in holding leaders accountable and building a stronger and more participatory society.
What Reimagined Leadership Should Look Like
This leadership model should learn from the best global practices while remaining grounded in African realities. As such, this leadership looks more like an institutional leadership style than a personality-driven one, relying on strong institutions and quality systems that endure even when those leaders are gone.
It must prioritise accountability over power retention, which means we must ensure our courts, legislatures, and press are independent, and that all anti-corruption agencies are monitored.
Leaders who choose inclusivity over top-down governance so that all citizens, women, and youths all have a significant role in the decision-making processes.
Africa’s reimagined leadership should be adaptive and future-oriented, addressing technological advancements, employment opportunities and economic transformations.
Africans must remember that although we may reimagine our leadership drawing on successful global democratic practices, we must retain our historical, cultural, and social realities as well as our traditional philosophies. For example, the famous Ubuntu philosophy emphasises that “All human beings are connected and should work together to support each other,” and can contribute by emphasising collective responsibility and the idea that political leadership exists within a relationship between leaders and society, not above it.
Conclusion
To conclude, when reimagining leadership, we shouldn’t focus on better individuals in power; we need systems that make good leadership possible and make poor leadership difficult to sustain. Africans must stop treating leadership as the possession of power and instead understand it as the stewardship of people, resources, and the future.
