Let’s do a quick survey:

Put a finger down if you’ve ever asked AI to help you put a thought into words before you even tried to write it yourself. 

Put a finger down if you ever had an idea, ran it through ChatGPT, and abandoned it because its response was better?

Put a finger down if you’ve ever asked AI what it thinks about something before deciding what you think about it?

Put a finger down if you’ve ever felt like your own writing wasn’t good enough until AI polished it?

Put a finger down if you’re no longer sure what your thoughts sound like without AI? 

I could come in and say something like “We’ve lost the use of our minds,” or “Authenticity is dead,” or my personal favourite, “AI is taking over,” but I’d be stating the obvious. 

Besides, I think the idea that AI is taking over is a little subjective. A more accurate way to look at it is that AI takes over the things we want it to.

Think with me:

If my house is AI-automated, it’s because I wanted it to be. I’ve observed a set of tasks that, while mundane, are necessary, and I’ve decided I’d rather have something else handle them, so I’ve given Alexa access to my lights, my curtains, and certain appliances. That’s the extent of its access because that’s where I need it; that’s where I want it.  

In the same way, if our thought processes have become AI-automated, we have reason to believe that it didn’t spontaneously occur. Access was granted somehow, somewhere.

AI, at its best, is a thinking aid. It can help us explore ideas, organise our thoughts and communicate more effectively. It can simplify our processes, but it shouldn’t have to replace those processes entirely.

Here’s the thing about thinking: it’s not always particularly enjoyable. Sometimes you have an idea, and you can’t quite figure out what to do with it. Sometimes all you have is an atom of an idea with no clue where it fits. And other times, you have absolutely nothing going on upstairs, and you have to sit there until something good arrives. It can be frustrating, embarrassing, or just plain annoying. Still, somewhere in that mess, you're learning to observe, make connections, and create something meaningful, and sometimes, nothing comes of it. That's okay, too. Not every thought has to become something for the thinking to be worthwhile.

In an age where generative tools exist at our fingertips with the ability to generate paragraphs of content in seconds, why would you sit in front of a blinking cursor for hours on end? Why struggle to write the perfect response to an email when you could have an entire paragraph beautifully articulated waiting for you before you finish your coffee? 

And honestly, I get it.

The problem, though, isn’t that we’ve found an easier way to do things; it’s that sometimes, in our haste to get to the finished product, we skip the very process that would have helped us get better at producing it ourselves.

Think with me. Every time you wrestle with an idea, you’re learning how to develop it. Every time you struggle to explain yourself, you’re learning how to communicate. Every time you make a horrible first draft, you’re learning what works and what doesn’t. 

In a 2014 study published in Cognitive Science, researcher Manu Kapur found that students who attempted to solve problems before receiving formal instruction developed a stronger conceptual understanding than those who were taught the solution first. In other words, trying to figure things out for yourself, even when you don’t get it right the first time, can become part of how you learn.

It’s an unconscious process, but those experiences make you better; when you consistently hand off those parts of the process to someone or something else, how much better could you really get?

I’m not implying that using AI to structure an essay means you’ve suddenly lost the ability to think, of course not. But I do think there’s a difference between using a tool because you’ve done the thinking and need a little help and using it because you haven’t thought about it and would rather not start.

One helps you move forward, and the other risks keeping you from discovering what you’re capable of.

So, how do we fix this? 

Here’s your step-by-step guide to thinking original thoughts.

STEP 1: Touch some grass.

Well, for starters, touch some grass. And I mean that literally. Go outside. Take a walk. Sit somewhere and people-watch. Have a conversation with someone without already mentally composing the perfect response while they’re still speaking; actually listen. Do something, anything,  that reminds you that there’s an entire world outside of the screen you’re currently staring at.

There’s a reason so many writers talk about paying attention to the world around them. Austin Kleon, the writer and artist behind Steal Like an Artist, has spoken about keeping a notebook, collecting little bits of inspiration, and returning to them later on to see what he can make of them. In an interview with The Kenyon Review, he explained that he drew on notes and ideas he collected over time to develop his book.

I like this because it reminds us that inspiration doesn’t always come as some grand, life-changing moment. Sometimes, it’s something you read, overhear, or a strange thing you notice on your way home. You might not know what to do with it at the moment, but all those things become material, and most of the time we don’t even notice we’ve stored them until weeks, months, or years later. They surface as an idea, sentence, a story, or perspective we didn’t know we had.

And that's part of the point of touching grass. You're giving yourself more of the world to think about. You're collecting experiences, not just information. You're allowing yourself to encounter things you didn't specifically ask to encounter, and sometimes those unexpected encounters give you something you wouldn't have thought to prompt a machine for.

The thing is, though, we can’t draw from experiences we never allowed ourselves to have, and it’s difficult to be curious about the world when you’re always looking down at a screen, waiting for it to tell you something interesting. 

STEP 2: Think before you prompt.

Now that we’ve established that you need to leave your house every once in a while, let’s talk about what to do when you get back. 

Before you open ChatGPT to brainstorm your next big idea, try brainstorming it yourself first. Before you ask it to explain a situation you’re struggling to understand, take a moment to figure out what you already think. Before you ask AI to write that email, caption, or deeply emotional message to someone you’ve been avoiding, try putting your own thoughts into words.

And if you’re not quite sure what those thoughts are, try journaling.

Journaling is the free expression of feelings, emotions, and thoughts by letting the hand and pen move across the page. 

Personally, I think of it as the simple art of putting pen to paper without friction, and there’s something about it that helps you sit with your thoughts a little longer. You don’t have to organise them neatly; you don’t have to worry about whether they make sense to anyone else. You can be angry, confused, heartbroken, cloudy, and a little unhinged. 

Journaling gives you the space to work through your yarn ball of feelings, however messy, intrusive, or slightly concerning they may be. It helps you recognise patterns in the way you think and separate your actual thoughts from what society imposes on you.

You don’t need a fancy journal or an ideal “Dear Diary” intro. Start with a question. 

What did I actually think of what happened? Why did that conversation upset me? What am I trying to say and why am I struggling to say it? Write whatever comes to mind and keep going until you physically exhale, your shoulders slack, and your mind is blank.

Then, when you're done, by all means, bring in the reinforcements. Ask AI to challenge your argument, point out what you've missed, or help you communicate your ideas more clearly. Just make sure there's an idea of your own in the room first.

STEP 3: Have an opinion of your own.

Sometimes, when we do manage to form thoughts of our own, we don’t always trust them enough to keep them. We ask AI for a second opinion and end up adopting it as our first. Sometimes, we have a perfectly reasonable idea until a more articulate, better-structured alternative comes along and suddenly ours feels inadequate. 

There’s a difference between changing your mind because you’ve encountered a perspective that genuinely challenges you and changing it because someone has presented their argument a little more convincingly.

AI can give you a beautifully structured argument and still be wrong. It can sound certain about something debatable, give you a perspective that overlooks important context, or offer an answer that is theoretically practical but does not account for the real-life constraints of that situation. If you’re not in the habit of questioning what you’re being told, you might never notice the difference.

This is why it’s important to develop your own opinions even if they’re a little messy.

Oxford Learner’s Dictionaries defines originality as the quality of being new and interesting in a way that differs from what has existed before. Still, originality doesn’t mean you have to come up with something nobody has ever thought of. It means allowing your experiences, observations, questions, and even biases to inform the way you see the world. It means being able to look at an argument and decide what you agree with, what you don’t and what you’re still unsure about.

Your first thought doesn’t have to be your final one. You’re allowed to change your mind. You’re allowed to discover, reconsider and revisit your opinions. You’re allowed to discover that you were wrong, but there should be some thinking in getting from one position to another.

So, the next time AI gives you an answer, ask yourself: Do I actually agree with this? Does it reflect what I believe? Is there something missing? Would I have arrived at this conclusion on my own? And if you disagree with it, don’t be so quick to assume the machine knows better. Examine your reasoning, look for evidence, and be willing to reconsider your position, because the goal isn't to become someone who disagrees with AI for the sake of being independent. It's to become someone who can think critically enough to agree or disagree for themselves.

And that matters beyond writing. It matters when you're deciding what you believe about the world, how you interpret other people's actions, what you stand for, and how you make decisions. If you become accustomed to having something else supply your arguments, opinions, and conclusions, you risk losing touch with the reasoning that makes those positions yours in the first place.

Your perspective doesn't become worthless because someone else can express theirs more eloquently. Sometimes, the thought you struggle to explain is the beginning of something worth exploring. Give it a chance before you dismiss it.

Now remember the automated house? The lights? The curtains? None of those things was a problem until we started confusing convenience with a reason to surrender control. AI isn’t the enemy here, and neither is convenience really. There’s nothing noble about making life unnecessarily difficult just to prove that you can. The point is to know what you’re automating, why you’re automating it, and what you’re willing to give up in exchange. 

Because the ability to think for yourself is about more than producing better essays or writing better stories. It’s about developing the judgement to decide what you believe, the curiosity to question what you’re told, and the confidence to recognise when something doesn’t sit right with you.

Those things take practice. They require you to sit with uncertainty, entertain ideas that might not go anywhere, and sometimes arrive at conclusions that are less polished than what a machine can offer you. Still, the process is how you develop your own perspective. And surely, that’s worth something.

So, by all means, use the tools. Enjoy them. Let them make things easier, but remember that you still have a mind of your own, and it’s worth exercising.

And if you stopped asking AI to help you think for a week, what parts of yourself might you rediscover?